Gary Marcus
AI criticism & cognitive science
NYU professor emeritus, AI critic and author. Known for skeptical takes on deep learning hype.
Recent activity
-
Oracle's stock has plummeted 61% since Gary Marcus predicted the excitement around its OpenAI deal was a "peak bubble" in September, and Nvidia, the "bank" financing the AI economy, is expected to rein in its deals due to its own financial struggles. The lack of technical moat in LLM companies also means they struggle to be profitable, leading to a collapse in the AI bubble. The outcome of this collapse is uncertain, but it may affect the planned IPO for Anthropic and mark a return to more structured governance and common sense in the markets. AI summary
Read more → -
The FAA has rolled out its AI flight-routing tool nationwide, aiming to reduce delays and shorten flight times, but the system has already experienced issues, including the cancellation of all United flights at Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR), prompting concerns about safety and oversight. This incident raises questions about the reliability and effectiveness of AI systems in high-stakes environments like air traffic control. The FAA's reliance on AI raises concerns about the potential for errors and malfunctions, particularly in systems with complex and interconnected components. AI summary
Read more → -
The valuations of companies heavily invested in generative AI, such as OpenAI, Anthropic, and Nvidia, have plummeted, with some experiencing losses of over 50% in the past few months, indicating a potential bubble bursting in the market. Training and inference costs are high, leaving little room for profits, and reliability issues with large language models (LLMs) persist. AI summary
Read more → -
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has resigned, leading to uncertainty over the future of the company and the AI industry, as his departure may lead to a collapse of the company's circular financing and potentially expose corrupt practices. The stock price has plummeted, and Congressional investigations are expected to continue, with China and US politics likely to be heavily impacted. The resignation may also affect Nvidia's plans for the Anthropic IPO. AI summary
Read more → -
Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei has made outlandish claims about curing various diseases, including cancer, Alzheimer's, heart disease, and mental illness, within 10 years, prompting criticism from experts and Eli Lilly CEO Dave Ricks, who described the timeline as "not likely" and emphasized the need for incremental progress. Many have compared Amodei's statements to those of Elizabeth Holmes, the founder of Theranos, and criticized the lack of scientific basis for such claims. AI summary
Read more → -
Nvidia is reportedly considering firing Jensen, potentially due to the potential liability and reputational damage associated with his business practices, which have been criticized for their ethics and circular financing. If Jensen is let go, it could lead to a reevaluation of Nvidia's commitments, including the billions promised to Anthropic in the IPO. This could have significant implications for the AI world and the companies involved. AI summary
Read more → -
Anthropic's proposed IPO valuation of up to $1.4 trillion is highly questionable given the company's lack of profitability, substantial future liabilities ($900 billion), and decelerating revenue growth, which has slowed by as much as 50% in Q4. The company's own filings admit to expecting increased costs and losses, and the AI industry faces a potential liquidity crisis. The valuation is largely driven by unrealistic projections that were based on the tokenmaxxing mania, which has since lost momentum. AI summary
Read more → -
Gary Marcus argues that Jensen Huang's problems stem not from a publicized affair, but from his recent defense of China's right to buy Nvidia chips, which he believes will damage his reputation as a lobbyist for China. This relentless defense has surfaced in recent interviews, potentially leading to his downfall. Huang's seemingly boastful behavior in sharing photos with his rumored partner, Alice Huang, may also be seen as unprofessional. AI summary
Read more → -
The Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has admitted to an affair with Alice Huang, a Chinese executive believed to be a spy, raising questions about who knew about the relationship and when, and whether Huang had access to sensitive information that could have benefited China. The incident is likely to lead to an investigation by Congress and could have significant implications for the tech industry and the US economy. Nvidia's stock price has already fallen in response to the news. AI summary
Read more → -
The global stock market experienced a $2.5 trillion drop, and a recent Bank of England study found that AI is not contributing to expected productivity gains, sparking concerns about the economic impact of AI. AI summary
Read more → -
The Generative AI bubble appears to have burst, with tech stocks, particularly those in the neocloud sector, experiencing significant declines. Investors are rotating out of smaller companies and into larger tech giants, which are better positioned to weather cash crunches. The market is now experiencing a widespread sell-off, with few companies exempt from the downturn. AI summary
Read more → -
The Pope's Encyclical on AI, "Magnifica Humanitas," emphasizes five key points for guiding the development of artificial intelligence: the future of AI is not predetermined, machines are tools not persons, certain decisions must never be delegated, intelligent technologies must serve the common good, and institutions are needed to put ethical principles into practice. AI summary
Read more → -
Anthropic's draft S-1 filing omitted Q3, a section that likely discussed the company's demand performance in the third quarter, which is significant given the decline of tokenmaxxing and the rise of low-cost alternative models. This omission may indicate a lack of transparency about the company's recent performance. The missing Q3 section may raise concerns among investors and analysts. AI summary
Read more → -
Generative AI is poised for a potentially record-breaking IPO, with Anthropic planning to file publicly on Monday, coinciding with a challenging week for the industry, which may impact its future development and adoption. AI summary
Read more → -
Gary Marcus argues that the negative effects of generative AI, including nonconsensual deep fakes, phishing scams, disinformation, and IP theft, outweigh its potential benefits, and that the technology's development has led to a "Code Red" situation, with significant risks to democracy and the economy. AI summary
Read more → -
CoreWeave's stock price has dropped over 50% in the last six months, despite efforts to boost it, and its current stock price is not showing significant recovery, with a recent blip possibly caused by TV hype. AI summary
Read more → -
U.S. banks are experiencing attacks from AI agents, with executives racing to restrict access to their systems as the technology advances at a faster pace than financial institutions can respond. This issue is part of a growing wave of cyberattacks worldwide, including those in France, Japan, and Latin America, highlighting the need for more comprehensive regulatory efforts beyond just focusing on "frontier" models. The misuse of existing models, not just future ones, is causing serious problems across society. AI summary
Read more → -
A recent article by Gary Marcus highlights the instability of the generative AI market, with tech stocks experiencing significant declines, particularly CoreWeave, which dropped over 15% in one day due to growing debt problems. AI summary
Read more → -
A new study found it remains "very difficult to find actual, materially measurable financial impacts" from spending on AI, echoing previous research on the topic. This challenges the widespread expectation that AI will significantly boost productivity and GDP. AI summary
Read more → -
The AI industry's valuation may be unsustainable due to concerns over potential liability from poorly controlled agents, a recent US appeals court decision undermining generative AI companies, and the decline of tokenmaxxing, leading some to question whether companies like OpenAI and Anthropic can truly justify their massive valuations. AI summary
Read more →